Breaking News
Local news

‘Safe and secure’: PA Secretary of the Commonwealth reviews election safeguards

By HUNTER SMITH hsmith@lockhaven.com 11 min read
AP Photo/Carlos Osorio Pennsylvania Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt, participates in an election forum, Thursday, Sept. 19, in Ann Arbor, Mich.

LOCK HAVEN -- Pennsylvania's top election official, Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt, assured residents that the state's election system is stronger than ever. "Elections in Pennsylvania have never been more safe and secure," Schmidt said in a recent interview with The Express, underscoring the state government's commitment to election integrity ahead of the upcoming general election.

Administering an election for perhaps one of the most consequential states on election day this Tuesday, Schmidt bears the incredible responsibility of guaranteeing the accuracy and legality of the nation's largest swing-state's elections.

Beset by allegations of misconduct on both sides, as the presidential election approaches, voters are deeply uneasy about the potential for political violence, voter fraud, foreign interference, attempts to overturn the election results and the broader implications for American democracy.

A survey by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research revealed that one in four respondents reported feeling either "extremely" or "very" concerned about legal or violent attempts to overturn the November election outcome. The study showed that a similar proportion fear increased violence directed at political figures or election officials, and that nearly one-third of voters are concerned that state or local election officials might block result certification.

A Republican chosen to serve as Secretary of the Commonwealth by Democratic Governor Josh Shapiro, Schmidt has an extensive history in election oversight and bipartisan efforts to uphold the integrity of US elections. He says that rebuilding trust in our electoral process begins with voter education and communication.

"In our effort to get it just right, we closely monitor what we see out there so that we make sure we are always messaging the truth at the same time others are messaging lies about elections, so people have access to accurate information in the hopes they won't be deceived by bad faith actors taking advantage of them and their real curiosity," said Schmidt.

While other states have taken varying approaches -- either actively countering disinformation or opting to ignore it altogether -- he said Pennsylvania has been closely monitoring online discourse ahead of the election and will continue to evaluate the spread of disinformation during and after voting concludes.

"While conspiracy theories require no basis in fact whatsoever to be created and shared, we want to minimize any opportunity for people to exploit errors in election administration and have them being misused to undermine confidence in our election results," he said.

Election administrator trainings

To address the high turnover among election administrators, Pennsylvania's Department of State formed a dedicated training team that, over the past year, has worked closely with new election officials to "minimize any opportunities or any possibility that they would make a mistake in an environment that is very time-sensitive and highly scrutinized."

Even if an error wouldn't impact a single vote or the final outcome, Schmidt made clear that administrators are committed to minimizing any chance of mistakes that could undermine public confidence in the election results.

In September, Melanie Bailey, director of the Centre County Elections Office, secured approval from the county commissioners for a contract with Election Systems & Software, LLC, to conduct a three-day poll worker training for the 2024 general election at The Penn Stater Hotel and Conference Center. Scheduled for Oct. 15-17, the training should help ensure that the people running polling places and processing ballots are knowledgeable, safe and capable of administering accurate, secure elections.

Bailey, who assumed her role as director on Aug. 6 of this year, previously served as the director of elections for Venango County in Western Pa. Because she is new to her role, Bailey herself attended the training as an aide and observer.

"The bottom line is we want to make sure elections run smoothly in Pennsylvania, and we've taken a number of steps to make sure that happens," Schmidt said.

Non-citizen voting

One way Pennsylvania election officials are working to ensure a fair election is by preventing ineligible individuals, including undocumented immigrants, from registering to vote.

"Pennsylvania has really been ahead of the curve on this interest in non-citizen voting, no matter how infrequently it occurred," Schmidt said. "The Pennsylvania Department of State took a very comprehensive approach to it and did so responsibly, unlike a lot of other states that you see now that are taking action on the eve of an election to cancel voter registrations, including registrations of citizens of the United States."

A recent Associated Press article cited over 1,600 voter registrations purged in Virginia over the last two months, culminating in a Supreme Court decision allowing the purge to stand.

"I was a Republican election commissioner in Philadelphia for 10 years (2012-2022), and I investigated hundreds of allegations of voter fraud, and in my work we found that it occurred very rarely," said Schmidt. What he found was that in the extent it was occurring at all, it was occurring through the Motor Voter Law (The National Voter Registration Act of 1993), a concern he raised with the Department of State back in 2016, years before he took the helm of the agency.

At the time, he was one of three members on the bipartisan Philadelphia Board of Elections, where he served as vice chairman. In that role, Schmidt worked to modernize election operations, improve efficiency and bring greater integrity to the election process.

Schmidt explained that non-citizens would visit the DMV, present their foreign passports, work permits or state identification, and at that same time, they would be prompted to register to vote, as this option was extended to everyone.

"Especially with language accessibility reasons, there were non-citizens who registered to vote during that process," Schmidt noted, pointing out that they were not automatically registered and that the practice continued for decades under both Republican and Democratic administrations.

Schmidt assured that since the issue was brought to the Department of State, comprehensive measures have been implemented to ensure that non-citizens would no longer encounter the option to register to vote when obtaining a driver's license. Additionally, anyone who was mistakenly registered was required to affirm their citizenship or cancel their registration.

Mail-in ballots

Pennsylvania has faced a wave of legal challenges to its election rules, many of which focus on mail ballots. Voting by mail is still a relatively new practice in Pennsylvania, which has opened the door for attempts to undermine public confidence due to a general lack of familiarity with the process, its safeguards and verification methods. As a result, there has been significant litigation aimed at addressing various aspects of the law that remain unclear or unresolved in the 2019 legislation, which was passed by a Republican-controlled state house and senate and signed by a Democratic governor.

In 2020, facing repeated unfounded claims of voter fraud -- since deemed baseless in a court of law -- Schmidt countered these allegations and resisted pressure from within his own party to stop counting mail-in ballots. His refusal to support efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election resulted in backlash from then-President Donald Trump on Twitter, who labeled him a "Republican in name only."

In 2022, Schmidt provided testimony to the Jan. 6 Committee, where he testified about his experiences with the Trump campaign's legally rejected claims of voter fraud in Philadelphia.

One case, decided by the Supreme Court on Friday, ruled that Pennsylvania voters may cast provisional ballots if their mail-in ballots have been invalidated. On the same day, a separate ruling by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld the requirement for voters to write the date that their ballot is completed and sealed on the return envelope, which will remain in effect for Tuesday's presidential election.

Schmidt said, despite the legal issues continuing to be decided, that voting by mail "is (a change) that has improved accessibility without compromising the integrity of the electoral process."

To help reassure the public of the security of mail ballots, Centre County Commissioners approved the sponsorship of CNET's live stream of the 2024 general presidential election vote-by-mail processing rooms at the Penn Stater Hotel and Conference Center and the Willowbank Building.

According to the commissioners, the livestream ensures anyone interested in seeing the process, but is unable to come to the processing places in person, is able to see the votes being counted.

"I think it's important that we provide this opportunity for transparency and for people to see how the process works, so they know when they put their mail-in ballot in the mail or in a dropbox, they have a sense of what happens on the other end," Commissioner Amber Concepcion said.

Foreign Interference

Another concern for many Americans revolves around the impact of foreign threats on our elections.

While reports released by the National Intelligence Council, indicted US intelligence saw "no indications that any foreign actor attempted to alter any technical aspect of the voting process in the 2020 US elections, including voter registration, casting ballots, vote tabulation or reporting results." They did assess, however, that Russia, Iran, Hezbollah, Cuba and Venezuela all attempted to influence voters in the 2020 and/or 2016 elections.

"We work closely with federal, state and local partners to always test for cyber security vulnerabilities and make sure the process is in no way interfered with," said Schmidt.

Since 2020, all voters in Pennsylvania have used paper ballots, which are subject to two audits after each election. This system eliminates any opportunity for electronic interference in the voting process.

To protect yourself from becoming a victim of foreign influence, it's essential to stay informed about specific tactics employed in these campaigns, including bots and trolls that amplify misinformation, deep fakes -- digitally manipulated videos and audio that create misleading narratives -- and unsourced polarizing content that can distort public perception and exacerbate divisions.

Certification disputes

The secretary emphasized that ensuring the certification of Pennsylvania's votes is a major commitment of his administration, and one which has involved traveling across the state to meet with election officials and county commissioners. "We are working closely with our counties, who really are responsible for running elections in Pennsylvania, to make sure that they have the support that they need to do their job and make sure that voters can cast their vote and make their voice heard," Schmidt stated.

He added that, "when it comes to certification, I'm confident that our county partners, who are professional civil servants, and commissioners will fulfill their responsibilities in the Pennsylvania Election Code to certify their voters' votes."

As of the last week of October, the secretary had visited every county in Pennsylvania. On Oct. 21, he visited Clinton County to meet with Commissioners James Russo, Jeff Snyder and Angela Harding, and on Monday, Oct. 14, the Pennsylvania Secretary of the Commonwealth visited and delivered remarks at the newly-opened West College Avenue Satellite Elections Office in downtown State College, where he discussed the importance of access to voting resources and the work counties and states do to prepare for elections.

Centre County Commissioner Concepcion reminded those in attendance at the opening that "It is your neighbors and fellow community members who are there to assist you with voting," and encouraged eligible voters to visit the office.

Additional information

"Voting, whether in person or by mail, is a very simple process. It is not complicated and is really something that we should all be celebrating, not something that we should dread given that it is the foundation of our entire system of government in our representative democracy," said Secretary Schmidt.

Even with all the ugliness surrounding the electoral process and political campaigns at times, Schmidt said that he hopes that "everyone knows that their vote will be counted, especially in a state like Pennsylvania where every poll has indicated that the race for president on down could be close."

Pennsylvania has released a guide of fact-checked Pennsylvania-related election claims, available online at www.pa.gov/en/agencies/vote/elections/fact-checking-pa-related-election-claims.html. Information regarding election security can also be found at www.pa.gov/en/agencies/vote/elections/election-security.html. For additional voting information, including voting times and locations, visit www.pa.gov/en/agencies/vote.html. Official election results will be available starting at 8 p.m. on Nov. 5 at www.electionreturns.pa.gov/.

Starting at /week.