Photo courtesy of Talen Energy Talen Energy’s Montour County power plant is shown.

Montour County on Tuesday rejected a plan to rezone land so a data center could be built there, becoming the latest locality to push back against an electricity-hungry industry growing rapidly nationwide.

The three county commissioners in central Pennsylvania unanimously denied the request by Talen Energy to rezone more than 800 acres from agricultural to industrial, a use that would have permitted an application by a data center developer. The rezoning would also have allowed expansion of a coal and gas-fired power plant that would have supplied electricity to electricity to the proposed data center.

Commission chair Rebecca Dressler said the proposed project would not benefit the community as a whole and that Talen had not met its burden of proving why the commission should rezone the land.

“No evidence was provided demonstrating that the benefits outweigh documented and foreseeable public harms,” she said in a statement before the vote that Inside Climate News viewed in a video recorded by a member of the audience.

Talen Energy said it still plans to develop a data center project in Montour County and will listen more closely to community concerns.

“This allows us to take the time to listen, incorporate feedback from the Commissioners, engage with the community, and refine our plans so they reflect local priorities,” the company said in a statement. “We remain committed to pursuing a path forward in Montour County. As we do, we will provide additional detail on how this project can create quality jobs and generate long-term tax revenue to support local schools, public safety, infrastructure, and other essential services.”

The denial surprised and delighted critics, some of whom expected the commissioners to grant the company’s request. Ginny Kerslake, eastern Pennsylvania organizer for the environmental advocacy group Food & Water Watch, called the decision a “David and Goliath” moment for opponents.

“Thanks to the incredible work of a community that tirelessly showed up and spoke out over the past several months, the request to rezone almost 1000 acres of farmland to industrial for a gas power plant expansion and data centers was unanimously denied,” Kerslake wrote on Facebook.

Local Pushback on Data Centers

The commission’s action follows an increasing number of government entities in the U.S. rejecting data center plans, mostly at a county or municipal level, according to Mitch Jones, managing director of policy and litigation at Food & Water Watch. The group has called for a national moratorium on further data center development until the industry’s effects on communities are better studied and understood.

Jones said local opposition to data centers is growing across the country, driven by public concern over rising electricity bills, the centers’ large water use and the health effects of air pollution on people who live nearby.

Two recent examples of successful local opposition to data centers have occurred in Chandler, Arizona, and Naperville, Illinois. But the trend is especially noticeable in Pennsylvania, where local people concerned about the years-long upsurge in fracking for natural gas were primed to organize against the latest boom, Jones said.

“Pennsylvania seems to be a hotspot for it at the moment,” he said. “It does seem that there is growing grassroots opposition in Pennsylvania that is increasingly successful. Because of the fracking boom, a lot of people on the ground in Pennsylvania are more familiar with how to stop industrial projects that they don’t like.”

According to Data Center Watch, an advocacy group that tracks the industry, 20 data center projects were blocked or delayed in the second quarter of 2025, the latest period for which its data was available. That represents a 125 percent increase over a year earlier.

In that period, 53 local groups in 17 states targeted 30 data center projects, two-thirds of which were blocked or delayed, the group said.

Tuesday’s denial “reflected the board members listening and responding to the voices of their constituents,” said Jackson Morris, who studies the state power sector across the country at the nonprofit Natural Resources Defense Council. “The residents of Montour County made pretty clear where they stood on this.”

——

This article originally appeared on Inside Climate News, a nonprofit, non-partisan news organization that covers climate, energy and the environment.

——

Pennsylvania Capital-Star is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Tim Lambert for questions: info@penncapital-star.com. Follow Pennsylvania Capital-Star on Facebook and Twitter.