Breaking News
Police, court and fires

Judge allows part of racial harassment suit against JSASD to proceed

By From Staff Reports 3 min read

JERSEY SHORE -- A federal lawsuit against the Jersey Shore Area School District and three administrators will proceed but with fewer claims than the initial filing.

The suit accuses the district and the administrators of being deliberately indifferent to racial harassment, according to information from Pennlive.

U.S. Middle District Judge Matthew W. Brann on Friday found Adam and Catiese Williams had provided sufficient information for part of their amended complaint to proceed to discovery, Pennlive reported.

Defendants in the case are the district, Superintendent Brian T. Ulmer, High School Principal Steven Keen and Assistant Principal Elizabeth Seagraves.

Pennlive previously reported that Brann, in May, dismissed the complaint but allowed the Williamses to file an amended one if they could allege new facts or more details on those previously alleged.

He expressed empathy for what the couple's biracial children allegedly endured and found they had suffered pervasive harassment and the district had actual knowledge of it.

But the judge ruled the Williamses failed to meet the very high standard for causes of actions against public schools and officials related to student bullying.

According to Pennlive, in their amended complaint the Williamses accused Ulmer, Keen and Seagraves of making "deliberate decisions based on racial animus" and not conducting adequate investigations, issuing effective consequences or taking reasonable and effective steps to end racial harassment.

The couple claims they were not provided evidence that corrective action was taken despite being assured their complaints were investigated is one of the reasons Brann gave for permitting part of the complaint to proceed.

The school district maintains it was unable to identify the harassers through its investigations, which included reviewing surveillance footage, Pennlive reported.

Like the original complaint, the couple noted the racial harassment never ended and they were compelled to remove their son and daughter and leave the district.

Their examples and dates of the racial harassment contained in the litigation include:

-- Fall of 2019 in middle school, the couple's son was told they wanted to sell him on the slave stage and wished they could travel back in time so they could own him as a slave and whip him. They made monkey noises at him.

-- March 2021, the daughter was called the N-word in class by a student, who later apologized. The Williamses were told an ethics committee that would include their daughter would be formed but it never was.

-- September 2021, the boy was subjected to being called the N-word and reminded that Blacks had been hung in the past when they didn't do what they were supposed to do.

-- December 2021, a racial slur was carved on the table in the cafeteria where the Williams boy usually sat.

-- January 2022, a student showed the boy a picture of a Ku Klux Klan member that was on his phone.

The Williamses contend these incidents were not included in the district's safe school reports, Pennlive reported. They are annual reports that school districts must submit to the Pennsylvania Department of Education containing data regarding incidents of harassment, including racial and ethnic intimidation, as defined by Pennsylvania law.

The result of Brann's order claims that will proceed are those under the Civil Rights Act against the district and the equal protection clause of the Constitution against the three administrators involving the couple's son, Pennlive reported.

Also moving forward are the equal protection and due process claims against the district involving both children.

Other claims in the amended complaint were dismissed.

Starting at /week.