Trending
The looming closure of Mansfield University is the latest tip of the spear in the long-running debate roughly lumped together as “rural issues.” In the last few days since the news broke, many people have weighed in and the range of their takes and attributions is quite a broad spectrum. We now join that conversation.
First, let us be utterly clear: this is a complicated situation, with complicated causes that stem from decisions made, quite frankly, before most of our staff were born. Fully unpacking this is more of a book-length matter, and not something you can expect to read in an editorial.
That having been said, let’s call to the forefront the most critical aspect of this: this will affect thousands of lives -- and livelihoods. Many people seem to think it is acceptable to keyboard-warrior with statistics and opinions that “well, everyone knew Mansfield wasn’t viable for years, they’re just dead weight!” (this is an actual take that we have heard).
Have a little empathy -- if not for your neighbors, then at the very least have the awareness that Mansfield just took a figurative bullet for us. It is overwhelmingly likely that it will cost many of them everything. Treat their community with the same respect that you would hope they would treat ours with had it been Lock Haven closing instead.
According to reporting from The Morning Call, “Mansfield University generated an estimated $111.8 million for the region's economy through its spending as well as the income and sales taxes generated by employees, students and businesses, according to a 2015 PASSHE study.” This is an enormous footprint to abruptly lose -- and once the businesses begin closing, what happens to the people who live there? Their homes will devalue, for one -- and the downstream effects of that will be crippling on thousands of people.
Did you know that Tioga County’s population, as of the 2020 census, was just over 41,000? That’s about 4,000 more than Clinton County! Much like for those of us here, that is their home: built around a university which has stood since 1866. For generations since, it would have been unthinkable that their university could close.
And yet.
Now, the collection of rural communities that are serviced by the university will fight for its survival, and, by extension, their own.
They should not stand alone.
But ultimately, the most important consideration for us, in our little wooded enclave: learn from this. Absolutely nothing says that our university will be here a decade from now, let alone two or three. There are two paths here: either the university must be strengthened, or the county must diversify and develop. These goals are not at odds with one another.
One of the best ways to strengthen the university is to create or attract more things to the region for college students to do. We have what, a couple bars? Some great outdoor activities? Aside from activities, we also don’t have many of the businesses that young people routinely utilize -- think Target, for example, or Starbucks (not counting the one inside the university itself). Yes, we have better options for coffee shops locally -- but if you are expecting students from out of the area to come here, you have to provide branded spaces that they will be comfortable with from the get-go. Moving away for college is stressful enough as it is, and the familiarity and uniformity of their typical shopping spaces can help ease that.
As for diversification and development -- consider that we are located much more centrally than Tioga is, nestled between two larger counties in Centre and Lycoming and their attending industries. However, Tioga has a higher GDP than Clinton does -- by about a quarter of a billion dollars, according to government data. It is up to us to find ways to innovate the means of standing more readily on our own. As rural Americans, one of our chief virtues is the belief in our own resilience. It is well past time to utilize that resilience to better the lives of those who live and work here.
Regardless, we have been given the gift of foresight. We can see what the future holds, and all that remains for us to do now is to act to prevent it. And, spare a thought for the citizens of Tioga County and the students and alumni of Mansfield University. Their lives have gotten harder almost overnight, and it’s not like rural life is that easy to begin with.
No matter how smug it might make those in better-off areas feel to say it, Mansfield University wasn’t asking for this, and Tioga County does not deserve it.
Victim-blaming is ugly and disgusting. Do better.