Breaking News
Letters to the editor

From insurrection to immunity

2 min read

Tim Mannello

Williamsport

January 6, 2021 was not a misunderstanding, a protest gone wrong, or a footnote in political history. It was a full blown assault on American democracy. A mob, motivated by Donald Trump's false claims about the election, stormed the U.S. Capitol and violently clashed with Capitol Police and D.C. Metropolitan Police. More than 140 officers were beaten, crushed, sprayed or trampled. Five officers died in the aftermath. One rioter died. The attack left nearly three million dollars in damage to the seat of the American government.

Federal prosecutors charged roughly 1,583 people. About 1,000 pleaded guilty. Six hundred sixty seven were sentenced to prison for crimes ranging from assaulting police to obstructing Congress itself.

At 1:21 p.m., President Trump was informed that the Capitol was under siege. For the next 187 minutes -- over three long hours -- he did not publicly act to stop the violence. Only at 4:17 p.m. did he finally release a message telling the rioters to go home.

In the immediate aftermath, several Republican leaders -- Mitch McConnell, Kevin McCarthy, Lindsey Graham, Liz Cheney and Mitt Romney -- condemned the attack in stark terms. But as time passed, all but Cheney backed away from supporting any meaningful accountability.

Then came November 2024. Voters returned Trump to the White House. And the day after his second inauguration, he launched a sweeping effort to recast the events of January 6 -- not as an attack on democracy, but as an act of patriotism.

He pardoned every January 6 defendant, including those convicted of seditious conspiracy. He celebrated imprisoned rioters, featured their voices in a recording of the national anthem, and labeled them "patriots." He demanded compensation for those he pardoned. He pushed for investigations into members of the House January 6 Committee, Special Counsel Jack Smith and other officials who had previously investigated him.

The story of January 6 has become a struggle over national memory -- a clash between fact and fiction. It is a story of an uprising and its aftershocks, of perpetrators recast as heroes, of criminal violence transformed into political mythology. It is the story of a day when democracy was attacked, and later, astonishingly, celebrated.

The elections of 2026 and 2028 will reveal which version of that story the nation chooses to carry forward: the documented day of infamy, or the rewritten tale of manufactured patriotism.

Starting at /week.